Monetizing Payments Data Responsibly Pays Off

Originally published in Financial IT

If you are opening a small kiosk near a university campus in the Netherlands’ biggest student city of Utrecht, make sure you stock more premium coffee than cheap coffee.

At least that’s what the point-of-sale transaction data* shows. We’ve all seen the news articles poking fun at broke millennials for spending too much on artisanal products and avocado toast, so it’s not a groundbreaking insight that they also like splurging on fancy coffee. But it’s only now with the advent of connected devices that trends can be quantified accurately and in real time.

Payments have become a seamless part of the customer experience, able to be now completed with a tap, a wave or a click. Despite their invisibility, payments data can yield rich insights about economic trends.

Building an ecosystem of insights
Traditional methods of understanding consumer preferences are no longer effective on their own. For instance, surveys are limited, inefficient and biased. Transaction data can provide far more granular insights to various stakeholders – from retailers and restaurants to corporations and investors. Institutional investors and economists are already using this data to make better decisions. 

This means companies, from retailers to payments firms, can create a new revenue stream by monetizing their data. Even when this data is anonymized, many are still concerned about unintentionally exposing the identities of their customers. However, the key is in aggregating the data in a way that doesn’t include sensitive information about any individual source. 

Aggregate data, stripped of identifying details, can still be a powerful source of insights. For example, we track data on beverage sales in on-trade channels (the industry term for restaurants, bars and cafes) across six countries in Europe. This data can be used in all sorts of ways. A business can use it to help price products competitively without having to physically visit all the other bars in the city. An international food and beverage (F&B) operator can use this information to decide on the best location for its new outlet. Meanwhile, the payments solution provider collecting this data can tap into it to serve merchant partners’ needs. This means the same data can have a meaningful impact across different organizations and across the whole value chain.

Our mission is to democratize access to this underutilized data so that someday, even a consumer can use this data to find out where the cheapest gin and tonic cocktails are in their city!

Bringing outside insights into the boardroom

Sometimes analyzing your own business data simply isn’t enough to provide the full picture.

According to research**, the rate at which companies are using external data sources is outpacing that of internal sources. In a more connected and complex world, organizations are starting to realize that their internal data is just one piece of the puzzle.

For instance, many companies may already have a good grasp of what they sold last week, last month, or last year. But this may not be sufficient to predict what will sell tomorrow. The most accurate predictors often come from external sources – forward-looking market trends, competitive intelligence and insights that provide greater understanding of the environment in which the business operates. For example, by looking at historical sales of premium alcohol in our dataset, one can make inferences about growing affluence or gentrification in certain neighborhoods. Now, imagine being able to get a sense of that in real time!

The problem is most merchants don’t have the capability to easily crunch through all this information. This creates an opportunity for their payments partners to help connect the dots. They can use this data in a strategic way to create new products or expose the data in a way that delivers value to merchants.

Merchants shouldn’t have to think about data, after all, and be distracted from their core business. What matters for them is getting actionable insights. For instance, insights on anonymous customers’ full wallet spend and basket composition can help merchants optimize their operations or improve the end-customer experience. 

Knowing what your customers purchase in your store or restaurant is one thing – but being able to access aggregate industry data is even more powerful. If we see that nachos and beer in the same transaction lead to an average 30% higher consumption in beer, then we can advise merchants trying to increase beer sales to include nachos on the menu. 

Getting data monetization right

As all the examples above show, a robust data monetization strategy is important for innovation, growth and a competitive edge. But many companies are also wary of the challenges of extracting value from such vast amounts of data.

This is why it’s important for them to find partners that can help them establish a strong and safe data foundation in order to build the business case and technical platform needed to effectively monetize data. This requires close collaboration and a unified approach that can turn their data into both revenue and insights.

*Coffee sales in Utrecht from October 2017 – September 2018

**Business Application Research Center, March 2018

Suburbia Goes to Japan: A Note from the CEO

The first Dutch ship arrived in Japan in the 17th century. It was called De Liefde, meaning love. Its arrival led to such strong links that, between 1639 and 1853, the Netherlands was the only European country allowed to trade with Japan. 

This trade was not only in physical goods, but in art, culture and knowledge. This knowledge sharing continues to this present day – in the shape of data.


As a data company, this special historical relationship between both nations sprang to my mind in September, when I was informed that Suburbia had become the first ever Dutch startup to be selected for Fintech Business Camp Tokyo – an accelerator program run by the office of the mayor of Tokyo along with Accenture Japan.


Over the last few months, I have spent a lot of time understanding Tokyo and eating my weight in kashiage and yakiniku. Apart from gaining weight, I have also gained new perspectives into the Japanese market and made many valuable connections within the industry. 


Many say it’s not easy for foreign firms to crack the Japanese market because of complex bureaucracy and cultural factors. This is precisely why the support of the Tokyo Metropolitan Government (TMG) and Accenture has been so valuable, in providing us with access to top domestic companies and counseling us on things big and small, including the intricacies of Japanese business etiquette


We recently concluded the program with a pitch in front of members of TMG, media and some of Japan’s leading companies. We showed how our Amsterdam-based startup is building innovative technology to solve some of the biggest problems facing both data providers and data users. This technology transcends borders – we can process data from anywhere in the world and transform it into a rich source of insights. 


Japan is interesting for us for several reasons. There is a growing shift from a cash-focused economy to contactless and payment apps, which will generate a flood of raw data. If collected and structured, properly and safely, this data has tremendous value. The Japanese government has already proposed policies to encourage the sharing of this ‘industrial data’ and companies are beginning to take notice. As the use of alternative data in investment decisions rises rapidly, Japan is uniquely positioned to leverage new data and use it to make better decisions for its large pension funds and asset management industry.


While we have been working with mostly early adopters based in Europe and the US, we are witnessing the global rise of alternative data, especially from the frontlines of great initiatives like the Fintech Business Camp. With four hundred years of history between the Netherlands and Japan, we hope to contribute to four hundred more.

-Hamza Khan, CEO, Suburbia

Data Monetization in a Pro-Privacy World

(First published on Dataconomy)

For over the last decade, some of the most successful companies on earth have made their riches by mining user data and selling it to advertisers. The big question is whether this will continue to be a sustainable business model with the ever-mounting scrutiny on data privacy and if not – what’s the alternative?

Many say the Cambridge Analytica scandal sparked a great data awakening by bringing to light the ways in which some companies were amassing and monetizing personal data about their users. As a result, Facebook was recently slapped with a record $5 billion fine and new privacy checks.

This isn’t a problem that is exclusive to the giants of Silicon Valley. In Europe, hefty fines have also recently been meted out to British Airways and Marriott for data breaches. As data protection complaints have doubled year-on-year, regulators will be getting tougher on companies to ensure their compliance with GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation).

Meanwhile, GDPR has driven a global movement as governments outside the EU, from Australia to Brazil, are set to introduce similar data protection regulations.

In addition, GDPR has helped to create greater awareness about data protection among the general public. The European Commission’s March 2019 Eurobarometer survey showed that about 67% of European citizens surveyed know what GDPR is.

The convergence of a compliance culture within organizations, stricter data privacy regulations globally, and consumers becoming more aware of their rights will continue to have a huge impact on businesses that profit from personal data, and even any business which collects it.

The situation demands urgency as the stakes have never been higher. According to a report by Gartner, by 2020, personal data will represent the largest area of privacy risk for 70% of organizations, up from 10% in 2018.

But better privacy for individuals doesn’t mean it’s bad for business. On the contrary, companies can use this opportunity to establish trust with customers while becoming more thoughtful and innovative about their approach to data monetization.

For many firms, data monetization has been inextricably linked with the personal data of their customers. However, they could be collecting, generating or archiving other types of non-personal data that could be valuable to certain end users. That is, the alternative data that may even be overlooked by the business generating it.

This data might be structured or unstructured, but new tools and technologies have made it easier to mine and process such data into insights. These insights could serve as timely intelligence to those in other sectors, like economists, analysts or investors looking to identify patterns and trends.

In fact, there are many use cases for such alternative data in the world of investing when every bit of timely information helps to gain an edge. This is where anonymized and aggregated data matters most and personally identifiable information has zero value. What economists and asset managers most want to know is how many soft drinks Coca Cola is selling across Europe this quarter, not whether John Doe bought a Coke.

The growing focus on privacy doesn’t mean data monetization has been taken off the table. Data will always be an important and valuable asset for any organization, but it needs to be harnessed with the full respect of individual rights to privacy. 

Disrupting payments and unlocking the value of data

(First published on Instapay Today)

PSD2: the latest tightening of data regulations will require strategic, operational and infrastructural changes for banks and financial institutions. 

Is it an opportunity or a threat though? Judging from current opinion, it appears the financial industry hasn’t quite made up its mind. If there’s anything worse for the sector than a clear and present threat, it’s uncertainty.

In a recent survey conducted by open banking platform Tink, one thing is clear, financial institutions dislike regulation. They named it as the biggest threat to their current business models. With the final PSD2 deadline looming on the horizon, there is little time for firms to get wrapped up in an existential crisis though. Most are soldiering on, despite their doubts, to ensure they can comply with the new directive. They are investing in digitization, greater security and privacy. 

However, it’s clear that they need to do more than the bare minimum in order to not only survive, but thrive, in this new ecosystem. For banks, payment service providers (PSPs) and other players, PSD2 unearths an opportunity for them to innovate and compete.

Data should increasingly be viewed as a natural resource like oil. Yes, data is the new oil is a somewhat tiresome cliché, but sitting on an oilfield is not much use unless you have the right tools, infrastructure and capabilities to make something out of it. In that sense, firms need to grapple with how they can turn what is essentially a commodity, into a competitive advantage.

To benefit from the opportunities that will arise from PSD2, there are two key approaches any financial or payments services firms can take in the new landscape:

1. Monetize their data – Increasingly, no one party will have a monopoly on data. This means firms will need to start thinking about how to leverage their distinctive data sets as part of a data monetization strategy – without compromising sensitive personal information.

When it comes to monetizing data, many are enticed by the opportunity, but they may view it as a challenge. They may raise questions over data ownership and privacy. 

However, there is great value in anonymized, aggregated information that is used for business or investment insights. In finance, the interest is in identifying broad trends and patterns – the focus is never on the who but the what and how much. That means it’s possible to extract value from this data while preserving privacy.

Outside finance, there are other examples of how sensitive data can be used in a way that benefits the public. For instance, Uber shares anonymized data aggregated from billions of trips taken by its users in order to help urban planning around the world. 

Transparent and responsible use of this data can open the door to new revenue streams. Data might not be the core business for many of these firms, but revenue from this can quickly become meaningful as the quantity and quality of data grow over time. 

The value of their data can also increase when combined with multiple sources for consumption by third parties.

It can sound counterintuitive to deal with the threat posed by open data by sharing it even more widely. But this allows firms to strengthen existing data and play a more important role in the transactional ecosystem. Payments providers are well-positioned because they have unique insights into both merchants and consumers. 

2) Get better customer insights – The changes that will be brought on by PSD2 will show that no incumbent can afford to rest on their laurels. The classic mindset of getting all your financial services from one provider is going to change. Many payment experiences will change and become more seamless.

One hot topic is instant payments. While consumers are the biggest benefactors of this trend, merchants can also benefit from it in a number of ways. Instant payments are data-rich so they can leverage real-time data like never before. 

What does this mean for firms in this industry both big and small? Well, it will become more important than ever to convert data to actionable insights. They can use such insights to improve the customer experience, drive loyalty and even introduce better offerings.

This can help incumbents become much more data-driven and customer-centric in their approach, leading to better decision-making. Meanwhile, smaller players that can nimbly respond to these insights can outmaneuver bigger competitors and eat away at their market share. 

Ultimately, firms need to tackle PSD2 from a strategic perspective and not just from a compliance perspective. The ones that proactively capitalize on these opportunities can future-proof their business and disrupt, rather than be disrupted.

An Alternative Way of Seeing Data Monetization

From early-stage payments fintechs to giant acquirers, every company is asking themselves the same question: “How can we turn our data into dollars?”

After all, most companies these days are to some extent data companies, whether they are aware of it or not. Many businesses try to leverage certain types of data they capture, but there’s also a lot of valuable ‘data exhaust’ they could use without ever sharing any personal or sensitive information. This is known as alternative data and it is being rapidly monetized and shared in the US and Europe.

What is data exhaust?

No, it doesn’t refer to the exhausting nature of big data. (Though there is something to be said about that too!)

Data exhaust refers to the excess data that is generated as a byproduct of a company’s operations. Simply put, it’s all the data the firm might not know what to do with, or might not think is relevant to its core business. This amount is much bigger than you think – Forrester reported that on average, between 60% to 73% of all data within an enterprise goes unused.

However, with advances in IoT, machine learning and artificial intelligence, this rapidly growing volume of exhaust could hold much untapped potential. In fact, this data exhaust could end up being converted into valuable fuel, whether for better decision-making or new ancillary revenue.

Why is data monetization so hard?

Firstly, many firms struggle with what data monetization actually means. Some paths to data monetization are more obvious than others. We’re living in an era when exploiting data for advertising or marketing purposes has become a huge concern. Even when there is no threat to personal privacy, organizations still have to navigate reputational risks if there is even a whiff of data misuse.

Secondly, trying to glean insights from all this raw and unstructured data can be like finding a needle in the haystack. It’s a significant challenge in terms of resources and infrastructure, requiring data expertise that is usually not found in-house.

So what can companies do to tackle this?

Two routes to monetization

These are the two primary paths to data monetization that companies can choose to take, though they are not mutually exclusive. In fact, both paths can intersect and one can lead you down the other:

1) Getting new business insights – This is an internally focused path that may not directly lead to money on the table. But it’s about leveraging data to improve operations or the customer experience. In turn, this could lead to higher profitability or greater efficiencies that result in reduced costs.

Alternative data can yield insights that we may have otherwise not considered. But it’s easier said than done because, as Forbes reports, 87% of executives are still not confident they’re able to leverage all customer data.

But first, every organization needs to take stock of its data assets and figure out which types of data potentially hold value. Then they need to assess whether they have the data management infrastructure, tools and resources to be able to extract value from it.

2) “Externally” monetize data – These days, the mere mention of “selling data” conjures negative reactions. But there are ways of monetizing non-personal data that is aggregated and anonymized. This can be valuable to people you may not be thinking of in ways you might not have imagined.

Opportunities may exist in markets that are new and unfamiliar to the data owner. For instance, firms can open up new revenue streams by selling their data to economists, analysts, investors and any other parties that are seeking to gain new and unique insights.

Raw data by itself can be one-dimensional. It is when data from different companies and sectors is combined and enriched with complementary data sets that real value is created. For instance, a company working with vendors across the country might have data on national beverage sales. It could track these sales and provide additional insights back to the vendors to help them improve sales and promotions. The company could also share this data with beverage brands so they can finetune and optimize marketing by city.

Think about it this way: Doing nothing with your data is the equivalent of keeping all your savings under the mattress. It seems like a safe bet, but it’s outdated and you get zero returns. Data monetization is a smarter investment – it seems daunting at first but if you can find a safe, meaningful use case, your company’s data becomes a revenue driver rather than a sleeping asset.